Washington Watch
November 16, 2026
Dr. James J. Zogby ©
President
Arab American Institute
What the Israelis are doing throughout Palestine is nothing more than an extension of the Nakba, in slow-motion. The worst case is Gaza, where Israel callously ignores a “ceasefire” by daily killing civilians, denying needed food, shelter, and medical needs to two million suffering Palestinians, and continuing to encroach on Palestinian lands compressing them into ever-smaller areas. But the situation in the West Bank (and by extension what the Israelis call “East Jerusalem” which, in addition to the Holy City, includes 28 West Bank villages) must also be considered.
To understand how this is an extension of the Nakba, it’s important to look back at what transpired in 1948 and why it happened.
When Jewish leaders in Palestine were presented with the 1948 United Nations partition plan, despite having reservations about how viable their proposed state might be, they nevertheless accepted it. While the area reserved for the Jewish State included 80% of all of the Jewish inhabitants of Palestine, the area’s population was still evenly divided between Arabs and Jews. And despite the fact that the partitioned area included almost all of the Jewish-owned land in Palestine, that amounted to less than 10% of the total area, while Arabs owned four times more than that.
The Arabs of Palestine rejected the partition. They felt it was unjust both that the Jewish state received the largest portion of land they owned and that despite being almost half the population of the new Jewish state, they were to be reduced to a minority.
Israel’s goal in 1948, as described by David Ben Gurion, who became Israel’s first prime minister, was to use force to create more favorable conditions for their proposed “Jewish state.” Ben Gurion and his allies laid out a detailed plan that involved terrorizing Arabs out of their homes in order to expand the areas set aside for their state. As this campaign of terror and evictions unfolded, armies from the surrounding Arab states responded. Israeli propagandists used this response to justify their tactics, claiming self- defense. But in reality, their campaign of terror began months earlier and no Arab army ever entered the areas set aside for the Jewish state. The Arabs only attempted to salvage the parts of Palestine that were to be the Arab state.
When the dust settled, 700,000 Arabs had been forced to flee, and Ben Gurion was able to boast of a “double miracle”—the new Jewish state had “more land and less Arabs.” In the years that followed, Ben Gurion’s plan continued to be implemented. Arabs who tried to return were shot and killed, their homes and lands were confiscated, and over 420 Arab villages were laid waste and plowed under. Where Arabs remained, in the Galilee and what was called the “Triangle,” their villages and towns were surrounded and their lands seized.
All of this was by design. And it is important to note this because the same design can be seen in the way Israel is operating, to different degrees, in both the West Bank and Gaza today.
Thirty years ago, I was in the State Department office of a member of the Clinton administration’s “peace team.” On his wall there hung a map of the West Bank with Areas A (under the control of the Palestinian Authority), B (under joint Israeli/Palestinian control), and C (under Israeli control), each in different colors. I was there to present a document I had prepared on Israeli impediments to the implementation of the Oslo Accords. Whether he was being naive or disingenuous the State Department official said, pointing to the green dots of Area A, “As we progress, these green dots will expand and be connected until Palestinians will be able to exercise control over the entirety of this land.” Based on my experiences working with the US peace team, the Israelis, and the Palestinians, I responded, “What if they’re never allowed to connect? And all we have are these little Bantustans surrounded by a hostile Israeli control?”
This is where we are today. During the first years of Oslo, the Israelis refused to allow Palestinians to develop an independent economy. Using their control over areas B and C, they constrained Palestinian movement of goods and people so that the major sources of income for Palestinians were serving as day laborers in Israel or Israeli settlements. When hostilities began and permits were denied to Palestinian workers, they became more dependent on aid or remittances from abroad.
In recent years, the Israeli plan to complete the conquest of Palestine has accelerated. What is unfolding in the West Bank isn’t, as the Israelis say, “actions by a handful of rogue youth,” but rather the implementation of the same slow-motion Nakba. Settlements and outposts are being placed in locations designed to cut off Palestinians from one another. Thousands of homes are being demolished, agricultural lands are being seized, Palestinians in smaller towns and villages that are in the way are being terrorized into leaving, consolidating them in areas where they can be more easily controlled.
The design is clear. The green dots of Area A will be severed one from another and never connected. This is not happenstance. It is an extension of the same thinking that brought on the Nakba or its elaboration in the infamous mid-1970s Drobles Plan, which envisioned completing the conquest of the West Bank by seizing land, expanding settlements, and building Jewish-only roads and infrastructure making a contiguous Palestinian entity an impossibility.
Taken together, Israel’s actions since the 1948 Nakba and its immediate aftermath, and continuing since then in Gaza and the West Bank, constitute an eight decade-long process of displacement and ultimately the erasure of the independent Palestinian Arab presence in their land.