Washington Watch
October 19, 2026
Dr. James J. Zogby ©
President
Arab American Institute
Israel’s three-year-long war on Gaza has had a transformative impact on multiple levels—all relevant to the Israeli-Palestinian arena.
Most obvious are the changes in US public opinion. While the views of Americans toward Israel have been souring for more than a decade and a half, the way Israel has conducted the war have both accelerated and deepened this negative trend and given it new content.
Going back three decades, polls showed that Americans had very favorable views toward Israel and not so positive views toward the Palestinians. Even with this, pluralities were opposed to the Israeli government’s policies of violating Palestinian human rights and persistent settlement construction in the West Bank. This disconnect between liking Israel but disapproving of their policies deepened among Democrats during the Obama administration in reaction to its rejection of the president’s insistence that they freeze settlements and Israel’s very public campaign to oppose the US-negotiated Iran nuclear deal.
The US partisan split in attitudes toward Israel widened during the first Trump administration in reaction to the president’s full embrace of Israel’s prime minister. But even then, American’s favorable ratings of Israel remained higher than those of the Palestinians.
In the immediate aftermath of Hamas’ shocking October 7, 2023, cross-border assault on Israeli civilians, President Biden offered Israel some important advice. Noting that he understood their pain and shock, he cautioned them not to make the same mistake the US made after 9/11. In the wake of that terrorist attack, the US had the support of much of the world, but the Bush administration pushed that opinion aside and instead invaded and occupied Afghanistan and Iraq, taking the lives of hundreds of thousands, costing it support worldwide.
Netanyahu ignored Biden’s public appeal and unleashed a ferocious revenge assault on Gaza’s people and infrastructure. Israel’s excessive violence, which has correctly been termed genocide, horrified a wide swath of Americans, transforming attitudes toward Israel and other deeper consequences that flowed from that shift.
It is no longer the case that Americans like Israel but disapprove of its policies. Recent polls show Israel has net-negative numbers. In fact, the favorable ratings given to Palestinians are now greater than those given to Israel. And this outlook is most pronounced on the Democratic side, with 80% of Democrats holding unfavorable views of Israel. What the polls also clearly demonstrate is not only animus toward Israeli policies but also a pro-Palestinian component that has never before been a factor in US politics.
This shift has had political consequences. Early in the conflict, when the Biden administration would not act to stop Israel’s war, a progressive coalition mobilized not only on college campuses, but also in over 300 cities nationwide which passed ceasefire resolutions. This coalition brought together young people, people of color, Arabs and Muslims, and progressive Jews. They made their impact felt in the 2024 election with evidence demonstrating that the Democratic campaign most likely lost support because it would not respond to the movement’s appeals for justice.
The impact of this coalition has been felt in this year’s congressional votes and elections. In the US Senate, 40 of the 47 Democratic senators voted to block some military supplies to Israel and more than 40% of the Democrats in the House of Representatives did the same. And in hotly contested congressional races, more than a dozen pro-Palestinian candidates have won their elections despite being heavily outspent by pro-Israel groups.
Another arena in which Israel’s behaviors have had a profound impact is within the American Jewish community. Long assumed (incorrectly) to be in lockstep with the Israeli government, American Jews are now deeply divided. A Washington Post poll showed that Jewish opinion on Israel’s war in Gaza is evenly divided, while a Jewish Electorate Institute poll has 50% of American Jews favoring stopping US aid to Israel and only 40% wanting to maintain this aid.
The internal debate within the Jewish community goes deeper, with not just younger, politically active, progressive Jews questioning their attachment to Israel and their understanding of Zionism, but older, wizened members of the community publicly speaking out on these issues as well.
All of this has caused a near hysterical reaction from the mainstream Jewish establishment, which has felt compelled to fight a rearguard battle to regain lost ground. They are pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into efforts to defeat pro-Palestinian candidates, to intensify efforts to have criticism of Israel equated with antisemitism and punished, and to wage a “hasbara” campaign to whitewash Israel’s actions in Gaza. To date, their flailing about—despite causing real pain to some candidates, students, and intra-communal strife—has not succeeded in moving the dial. Their efforts are reminiscent of the story of the little Dutch boy trying in vain to put his finger in the leaking hole in the dyke. The continuing devastation wrought by Israel on Palestinians has resulted in changes that cannot be erased.