What Came Before October 7, 2023

Washington Watch

October 12, 2026

Dr. James J. Zogby ©

President

Arab American Institute

In any discussion of the impact of October 7, 2023, two facts must be acknowledged. Israeli-Palestinian history didn’t begin or end on that date, and it is both indecent and insensitive to suggest, as some have, that the painful impact of the terror inflicted on that day, by itself, has been responsible for the dramatic transformations that have occurred in the three years that followed. 
 
What we know is that the parties involved in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict were all guilty of horrible miscalculations that led up to both Hamas’ deadly cross-border assault and the Israeli actions in response. For decades, Israel’s occupation had strangled Gaza, restricting Palestinian opportunities to grow their economy or leave the territory to travel, trade, and even to seek needed health care with the outside world. Israel also imposed controls on imports, for an extended period even limiting the amount of foodstuffs allowed into Gaza to the per-capita caloric intake needed to sustain life. 
 
At the same time, the Israeli government callously saw it in their interest to support Hamas’ role in managing Gaza. They allowed Hamas to receive tens of millions of dollars each month to support governance. It wasn’t out of affection for the group, rather it was because Hamas relieved Israel of the burden of administering the territory and furthered their argument that they had no Palestinian partner with whom they could make peace. And while the Israeli government clearly saw Hamas as an enemy, it was one they felt they could control with periodic “retaliatory” bombardments that would be followed by “periods of calm.” 
 
For its part, Hamas settled into its role administering and controlling Gaza. It found ways to supplement its income through black market imports and taxation, while still maintaining its “resistance” mantle. In response to Israeli provocations in Jerusalem and the West Bank, Hamas would launch mostly harmless rockets, creating the impression that they were “resisting” while the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank was increasingly being seen as ineffective in standing up to Israel’s hostile actions. With that calculation, it appeared not to matter to Hamas that Israel’s responses to their primitive rockets were often disproportionate bombardments that resulted in huge numbers of Palestinian casualties.  
 
At one point, Hamas tried a new tactic by mobilizing largely nonviolent demonstrations against Israel’s closure of Gaza. The Israeli response was characteristically brutal, with snipers shooting young Palestinian demonstrators from hundreds of yards away, killing and wounding hundreds who posed no real threat to them. 
 
While the Gaza pot was boiling with no relief in sight, the US, through several administrations, did nothing to turn down the heat—neither pressing the Israelis to respond to Palestinian needs nor providing assurances and hope to Palestinians that their concerns were on the US agenda. For its part, the Biden administration’s assessment of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict matched that of the Israelis with Biden’s National Security Adviser saying as late as the end of September 2023 that the Middle East was calm and that steps were being taken to advance a broader Middle East peace without considering the plight of the Palestinians. 

 
Seen in this light, Hamas’ attack may have been, as some have speculated, intended to shock the Israelis and Americans into addressing their frustration or as a warning. It is interesting that in recent weeks it has come to light that Hamas did in fact send warnings of an imminent attack through a number of intermediaries. And here we find yet another set of miscalculations and questions that must be answered. 
 
Why did Israel ignore the warnings passed on by the UAE, Egypt, and Jordan? Were they looking for an excuse to “clean out” Gaza, once and for all?   
 
It seems unlikely that leaders in the UAE, Egypt, and Jordan—all US allies—could have passed Hamas’ warning to Israel, and not told the Biden administration? If so, why did the US do nothing? 
 
Given their experience with Israel’s brutally disproportionate responses to their rocket launches, did Hamas not realize that by kicking the “hornets’ nest” with a substantial cross-border attack that would result in the deaths of hundreds of Israeli civilians the Israeli retaliation would be massive? 
 
This brings us to the third set of miscalculations. In the days immediately following October 7th, Netanyahu began sending ominous messages making it clear that he intended more than just retaliation or revenge. On a few occasions he made reference to the biblical fate meted out to the Amalek—that was genocide. This was amplified by members of his government who called for letting no food or water into Gaza and the death and/or eviction of all of its people. 

 
When it became clear that Israel’s intention went beyond retaliation and was focused on making Gaza uninhabitable, why did the US do nothing to rein them in? Early on, Biden administration officials made it clear that they supported Israel’s goals in Gaza and would not call for a ceasefire until Hamas was eliminated. Did they actually believe that the eradication of Hamas could occur without the deaths of tens of thousands of Palestinians? And as they watched Israel destroy the majority of Gaza’s infrastructure, its homes, hospitals, schools, water purification systems, and roads, did they continue to believe that Israel’s goals were political and not genocidal? 
 
So much for the evil intent and miscalculations that got us into this nightmare, in a follow-up article we will look at what has been its continuing fallout. 

Previous
Previous

The fallout from October 7th and the genocide that followed

Next
Next

When “Democracy” Becomes an Obstacle to Peace