When “Democracy” Becomes an Obstacle to Peace

Washington Watch

October 5, 2026

Dr. James J. Zogby ©

President

Arab American Institute

While proponents assert that the spread of democracy is essential to securing peace, two allied democracies—the United States and Israel—are engaged in wars that are actually being exacerbated by the fact that both countries are in the midst of elections. 
 
From the beginning, in the American mind, democracy has been seen as more than just a form of governance. Both Liberals and Conservatives have idealized and elevated the idea of democracy into the equivalent of religious doctrine, making exaggerated claims about the benefits that accrue to societies that are democratic. We have been told that democratically elected governments are: more tolerant, more respectful of minority rights, more accountable for their actions, and less likely to start wars. Given this mindset, several past US administrations have made the spread of democracy a foreign policy priority, arguing that it was essential for world peace. 
 
While the US and some of its allies flaunt these attributes, boasting that their democracies place them above societies with other forms of governance, in reality, their claims of purity and adherence to ideals do not hold up to scrutiny. 
 
The glaring contradiction between the values we and other democracies espouse and our actual behaviors have been clear since our founding. After all, the American experiment with democracy was built on the backs of slave labor and the genocide of Native Americans. And more recently, when the George W. Bush administration launched its campaign to promote democracies worldwide, it did so while blundering through a devastating “war of choice” in Iraq and torturing prisoners in “black sites” they had suborned other countries to make available to US interrogators. 
 
Much the same can be said of Israel, who we and they tout as “our closest ally” and the “only democracy in the Middle East.” Like us, Israel claims that its democracy elevates it above its neighbors, making its actions more just and its behavior more moral. And like true believers in any ideology, when it is pointed out that reality doesn’t agree with their claims, they deny it and attack whoever has pointed out the disconnect. 
 
The fact that democracies hold elections provides them with yet another reason to boast of their superiority. However, as we see playing out in both Israel and the US, instead of providing a cleansing moment, elections are often used by contesting parties to justify bad behaviors and exacerbate social tensions. 
 
President Trump, for example, needs a way out of his no-win war with Iran, especially because of its negative impact on the economy and consumers, and the insecurity and instability it’s fomenting in the Gulf. But he is loath to look weak by ending the war without some claim of victory, because of the negative impact that might have on his legacy and his hold over his base voters—whom he needs to turn out in November to deliver a GOP victory. And so, he continues his bellicose language and threats toward Iran. 
 
Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu may have assumed that he could manage a governing coalition of parties even more extreme than his own. But his partners have used their positions to aggravate tensions with Palestinians in both Israel and the occupied lands. And when Netanyahu felt compelled to sign onto ceasefires that were supposed to stop the bombing in Gaza and Lebanon, his agreement proved hollow. In the face of criticism from his opponents and even his coalition partners that he was compromising Israel’s security by not “finishing the job,” he has continued to violate both ceasefires with impunity, while doing nothing to rein in the widespread terrorist violence in the West Bank being fomented by his allies. He feels he must do this because he cannot afford to lose any of his governing partners or he’ll be out of office. 
 
The bottom line is that in both instances, instead of implementing the values claimed to be the attributes of democracy, these elections do the opposite. Political discourse becomes coarser and more divisive, social tensions are aggravated, and warlike behaviors are promoted.  

Especially troubling is that while reporters and commentators know that the words and actions of both Netanyahu and Trump are directed more at appeasing their constituents than they are at the realities in Gaza, Lebanon, or Iran, too often they sin by omission and treat the political posturing as if it were real. For example, instead of being honest and treating Netanyahu’s claims that villages in south Lebanon need to be demolished to fend off his opponents’ accusations of weakness, they report it as if leveling whole Lebanese villages is needed for Israel’s security.  
 
Sadly, this is what has become of our democracies. 

Previous
Previous

What Came Before October 7, 2023

Next
Next

Don’t Look to the Democratic National Committee to Change Middle East Policy, That’s Not What the Party Does